Pre-order your Thanksgiving desserts today!
We’ve got plenty of delicious treats in store for the whole family, from tried and true classic flavors to enticing seasonal options.
We will be CLOSED Thanksgiving Day AND Black Friday, but we’ll be open regular hours (10-7) on Wednesday, November 24th, with lots of fresh-baked goodies.
**Pie pre-orders must be submitted by 7pm on Wednesday, 11/17.**
Quantity minimums and other ordering parameters may apply.
We will have a limited supply of 9″ pies in select flavors to stop in and purchase during the week leading up to Thanksgiving, though we encourage customers to pre-order whenever possible!
We offer full-size 9″, individual-size petite, and bite-size mini pies.
Mini/bite size (min. 24 per flavor)………………………$3-$3.25 each
Petite/personal size (min. 12 per flavor)……………..$4.50-$5 each
9-inch/family size (no minimum)……………………….$22-$25 each
Our Pre-Order Thanksgiving pie flavors include:
Apple * * *
Cranberry Apple Walnut
Good Times (Berger Cookie)
Chocolate Peanut Butter
* = also available in gluten-free
* = also available in vegan
* = also available in “glegan” (gluten-free AND vegan)
If you miss the pre-order cutoff date for pies, you can visit our online store between Thursday, 11/18 and 9am on Wednesday, 11/24 to see what options we have on-hand and place same-day pie pickup orders.
Our pies freeze very well, so you can always purchase through the online store a few days ahead to guarantee you get what you need, and then keep them in your freezer at home until Thanksgiving!
**Cupcake pre-orders must be submitted by 2pm on Sunday, 11/21.**
We will be baking as many cupcakes as possible for the shop, though we encourage customers to pre-order whenever possible!
There is a minimum requirement of 6 cupcakes for pre-orders.
Our Thanksgiving cupcake menu includes:
Vanilla Birthday Cake
Cookies n’ Cream
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Sweet Potato Surprise
Cranberry Apple Cider
Salted Toffee Crunch
Gluten-free: Vanilla Birthday Cake, Black Bottom, & Pumpkin
Vegan: Pumpkin, Cookies n’ Cream, Mocha, & Vanilla Chocolate
If you miss the pre-order cutoff date for cupcakes, you can always stop in on Wednesday, 11/24 between 10am and 7pm – though the earlier the better – to see what’s available.
OR, you can still use our online store between 8pm on Tuesday, 11/23 and 9am on Wednesday, 11/24 to reserve and pre-pay for cupcakes to be picked up on Thanksgiving eve.